In 2008 changes to the Ontario Human Rights Code came into effect allowing Ontario’s courts to award damages for infringements of the Code. Prior to these amendments such damages could only be awarded by the Human Rights Tribunal. In Ontario a claim in court still may not be commenced solely on the basis of a breach of the Code, it must be combined with another claim already before the court. So far in Ontario it appears that human rights claims are most often combined with employment law claims for wrongful dismissal.
In September 2013, more than five years after the 2008 amendments came into force, the first Ontario court decision was released that awarded damages under the Code. In the case of Wilson v. Solis Mexican Foods Inc. the court found that an accountant who was dismissed from her employment, ostensibly due to a reorganization, was in fact discriminated against and was awarded damages for both wrongful dismissal and for discrimination. The court found that the employer actually dismissed the employee not because of a reorganization but because she was absent due to a back injury. The employee had supplied her employer with doctor’s notes suggesting that she could return to work on a part time basis but the employer did not offer any such accommodation prior to dismissing the employee.
The amount of the human rights damages awarded by the court in the Wilson case was not insignificant. The employee was awarded $20,000.00 in addition to three months of salary for the wrongful dismissal. Of significance is that the trial judge found that the employer’s breach, in not offering any accommodation to the employee, was significant and this appeared to be an aggravating factor.
Many Lawyers and employers have expressed disappointment in the wide range of damages that are awarded when human rights complaints are litigated in front of the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal. Hopefully as more Ontario courts begin to award damages in these cases the potential quantum of these awards will be become easier for everyone to predict.